Member Offer
  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

External Hard Drive

Discussion in 'General Software & Hardware Forum:' started by Tom Sound, Sep 15, 2009.

  1. Tom Sound

    Tom Sound Active Member

  2. Western Digital do good passport external hard drives :) got a 250gb one myself.. their 1tb ones are good too apparently :)
  3. Levi

    Levi Moderator Staff Member

    Personally I just bought a caddy and then stuck in my preference of drives, ibm hitachi in my case (yes the deathstar brand but they have/are the most reliable brand I have used).
  4. Becky

    Becky Member

    Seconded, I have 2 of them, they're brilliant
  5. charles

    charles Senior Member

    Either a SATA hotswap bay with a drive or a sata card with sata hd in caddy..

    or as levi said a caddy from ebuyer, microdirect or the like and a hd of your choice inside... a simple but fun 5 minute project :)

    all depends on whether you will be docking it out and about or if it's just to expand current system memory.
  6. Thewholehogg

    Thewholehogg Active Member

    Thirded! I also have a 250 no probs and I've had it about a year and a half.
  7. Mohammad

    Mohammad Guest

    This morning I saw the exact same 1tb hardrive from Seagate for £55 (Buy it now) inc PP in ebay, It just sold out now :(
  8. kurtiscaston

    kurtiscaston Member

    I also agree with Western Digital. My film teacher has one, and so does my friend. Both are very happy with it.
  9. tim

    tim Senior Member

    i have a 1TB mybook. very gooood.
  10. charles

    charles Senior Member

  11. Tom Sound

    Tom Sound Active Member

    Thanks for the tips and link. I don't need a portable but the western digital units looks like they would be ideal for work. This requirement is for my home office for backing up/freeing up space so high speed is not essential. I'm going to read some more reviews, hadn't even thought of doing that thanks Charles.

  12. charles

    charles Senior Member

    If it doesn't need to be portable why not just add a new internal hard drive will only cost around £30 and will be a simple case of plug and play.

    SATA -
    IDE -

    ^^ cheapest viable options...

    Personally I avoid maxtor HD's as have had nothing but hassle from them; in fact every maxtor I have installed or caddied has died or had S.M.A.R.T probs.

    If you were looking along the external this enclosure is pretty nice:

    holds two drives, i'd put two of those samsungs in there and use one for system backup and one for documents also this card is a cheapo but i'm sure would do te job:

    total cost would be around £120

    What pc do you use?
  13. Tom Sound

    Tom Sound Active Member

    I know what you're saying, but I do want to be able to lock it away when I go away.

    Since I was burgled everything goes in the safe :)

    It's an intel mac pro, I've already got 2 500GB internal drives.

    Thanks :D
  14. charles

    charles Senior Member

  15. jason_ballard

    jason_ballard Junior Member

    i recently went through a similar dilemma as I had run out of room on my external Lacie drive. I have always been a great fan of Lacie products, I have the screen etc and I have always recommended their products over the years.

    I began my search for a reasonably priced 1TB external hd that would also give me a good transfer speed. From endless searching and reviews I come to the conclusion that the Western Digital My Book Studio Edition was the best solution. The thing that made my decision was the various different connections, including the common high-speed links eSATA and Firewire 800 :D

    My Book Studio Edition 2 TB Hard Drives ( WDH1Q20000 )

    I currently have an internal Seagate drive in my G5 and I have unfortunately got a dodgy one, which could drop out any day. This has obviously lowered my opinion of Seagate, hense the move to Western Digital.

    I hope you find what you are looking for :D
  16. Tom Sound

    Tom Sound Active Member

    Good Advice Jason thanks for that, interesting to hear the seagate isn't the most reliable, with all the Western praise on here I'm closer to making a decision, thanks y'all

  17. Greg

    Greg Active Member

    I'm currently running a Seagate FreeAgent Pro, and touch wood not had any problems with it, also came with a 5 year warranty, although that's not much help if it ever does have a serious error and you lose the data!
  18. Tom Sound

    Tom Sound Active Member

    Well, I ended getting a Western Digital Mybook 1TB in the end and it's great

    Got it from which seems pretty reasonable at £70something quid :D

    thanks all!

  19. matt

    matt Member

    If you get a 2TB drive but with 2 x 1TB SATA drives, you can then format it to RAID 1 which basically gives you 1TB of storage but automatically mirrors everything onto the other 1TB. As they're separate drives if one should fail you have an identical copy on the other.

    It obviously makes it an expensive 1TB drive, but with added security. And if it's full of commercial projects etc. then it's certainly worth it.
  20. jasonwall

    jasonwall Member

    We used western digital throughout the company and had 5 1TB mybooks of which 4 crashed and burned, unable to retrieve any information, they lasted just over 2 years. We may of been extremely unlucky but I personally wouldn't touch a western digital again.

Share This Page