Which icon do you guys prefer?

[matt3224]

http://imattic.com/1.png
http://imattic.com/2.png
http://imattic.com/3.png
http://imattic.com/4.png
http://imattic.com/5.png

 

[matt3224]

or....

 

[Toppers]

Hi Matt,
none of your links currently work!

 

[matt3224]

Thought that may happen...

Goto icons | iMattic | Apple News, Secrets & Rumors | iOS, OS X, iPad & Mac

 

[ARRIVALS]

Hi Matt,
none of your links currently work!

Same with me. But I'll take a random shot, at number 3! :icon_thumbup:

 

[matt3224]

Try...

It seems if you click the links i first posted then do a refresh they work

 

[ARRIVALS]

Ha. After checking the new link out, I would actually go with number 3 ahead of the rest. :icon_thumbup:

 

[Toppers]

I prefer number two, because it's a complete rip-off of an apple button :icon_tongue_smilie:

 

[Paul Murray]

I like the texture in number 4 but they're all pretty similar.

 

[djb]

Number 4. Never number 2.

 

[Chris Wiltshire!]

For news related, I would pick number 4.

Number 7 is nice though!

 

[matt3224]

Number 4. Never number 2.

Awesome thanks to all of you i will go with a tweaked version of no. 4

P.S. If anyone fancies Beta testing or blogging for iMattic let me know.

 

[richimgd]

They're all very iOS inspired although maybe that is the point? The first logo is nice and bright but its very generic too as its your standard iOS gloss effect. The second logo has the same background as iCloud it looks too much of a rip off as its one of iOS's core features. I'm sure the texture on the other logos is lifted from iOS too.
The fourth logo is the one I prefer because its bright and you have manipulated the texture in a nice way and interesting way and is more destinctive which is what you want.

Its probably better to present icons at their actual size rather than the huge size as they are currently.

 

[spottypenguin]

Number 3 closely followed by Number 4, ditch 2 - unless you want Mr. Legal Apple to come knocking

 

[Squevasquidge]

Number 3 for me!