Well right now I will say number one because that's the one I can see.
Though the layout yes I think is nice, a header, then a nav bar, then the content then the footer. Personally I'm not fond of the bar above the footer, but the colours all go nicely together, and it's kind of the same logic to my site, it's basic, but simple and good looking.
(ignore the basicness of the homepage, that'll soon get improved lol)
Though I will be updating it a little having instead a slide out side menu like I've done in these sites I'm doing for my friend and for my gaming community I'm part of.